Critique of Women In The Middle Ages
Introduction In this critique of Women In The Middle Ages, I will identify the Gies' purpose in writing this book and discuss how well they fulfilled their purpose. Also I will evaluate the merits and shortcomings of this book in relation to the themes, sources used, and the authors' writing style. Authors' Purpose The Gies assert that researching and writing about women in the Middle Ages is difficult, due to the sources that are commonly used and which gives a misogynic view of women, such as the writings of Church fathers, contemporary law books, and literary works. The Gies attempt to describe the lives of women in the thousand years known as the early Middle Ages, Dark Ages, and High Middle Ages. The first section of the book offers background information on the lives of women in the early Middle Ages, and the last section are individual portraits of specific women in the High Middle Ages. The Gies explore several elements that affect women's lives: childbirth, survival, marriage, property rights, legal rights, education, work, political roles, and religious roles. Authors' Writing Style Despite the difficulties in writing about medieval women, the Gies do an excellent job of providing the reader with an extended, if not complete, view of the lives of these women. They must necessarily fill in some blanks that history has left us, but the majority of their conclusions seem very logical and believable. For instance, the pervasive belief that women had few legal rights is shown to be not strictly true in the descriptions of the woman who disinherited her son in favor of a kinswoman (21) and other examples of women maintaining control over their own property. The manner in which the Gies trace the fluctuating status of women in the Middle Ages is seen to be directly connected to politics, economics, and changing social structure. For example, the introduction of the feudal system in ninth century France and, subsequently, other European countries, traces how women’s rights and status diminished due to the linking of land ownership to military service. The Gies' style of writing is clear, informative, and extremely interesting. I enjoyed very much how they presented the age old myths surrounding women, and in some instances, modifying them to reflect their actual historical elements. For example, the chapter entitled "Eve and Mary" describes the tendency on the part of males that "simultaneously placed woman on a pedestal and reviled her as the incarnation of evil" (37). This is important because it still affects the modern world. The Gies also present evidence that shows the conflicting attitudes towards women that men held. An early medieval churchman Tertullian thought of his wife as his "beloved companion in the Lord's service" while preaching to women that they were the "gate of the devil," "traitor of the tree," and the "first deserter of Divine Law" (38). While most of the conclusions reached by the Gies seem valid and logical, there is one that I cannot agree with. Regarding Blanche of Castile, the Gies write that "Blanche had never really exhibited a taste for power" (119). I believe that Blanche, once having obtained power, was clearly determined to retain it. The evidence of her possessiveness towards her son King Louis and her attempts to reduce his wife's influence over him demonstrates that Blanche was endeavoring to hold on to her political authority she had held as her son's regent. Authors' Sources The Gies used primary sources for the most part in writing their book. These sources are principally "chronicles, tax rolls, legal and manorial records, private account books, diaries, and letters" (5). They did use a few secondary sources, such as works by Frederick Engles, Jill Tweedie, and Marc Bloch. They seemed to draw much of their material from religious works, such as the Bible, and works by St. Thomas Aquinas, St. Jerome, St. Augustine, and St. Bernadine of Siena. Conclusion This was an excellent book to use for studying the lives of medieval women. Despite how much modern scholarship has advanced in presenting women, it still remains inadequate in traditional history texts. So therefore, supplements are necessary and this one provides an in-depth view of medieval women of all classes. I enjoyed this book very much and the primary reason is that it showed me just exactly how far women have advanced in modern society. Some of the evidence presented by the Gies was frankly shocking, such as the view that menstrual fluid was poisonous and that women were forced to walk the fields as a human insecticide.
Other Articles
Romance Novel with Relationship Advice is a Cult Classic Book Review: "Opening Love's Door:The Seven Lessons" by Dr. Diana KirschnerThe author's main point is to help Janna in finding love in the romance novel, “Opening Love’s Door: The Seven Lessons.” Kirschner, carrying out the purpose very well, shows how you have to control all the aspects of your life in order to bring love into it. I f ..."The Psychological Immune System" by Herman Kagan: Book Reviews The Psychological Immune System by Herman Kagan AuthorHouse (2006) ISBN 1420890050 Reviewed by Paige Lovitt for Reader Views (8/06)“The Psychological Immune System” was written to educate us on how the psychological immune system ties into the biological immune system. The author takes his theories beyond the individual’s f ...100 Promises to My Baby (Book Review) When I read the first few pages of this book, I thought to myself that I had come across, finally, a book that goes further than a how-to baby book in the physical sense.I also have to admit that what hooked me in the beginning was the quote from Tagore, opposite the contents page. "Every child is born proof that God has not given up on h ..."The Miserable Mill" by Lemony Snicket “The Miserable Mill” by Lemony Snicket is one of the series of events that happen in the lives of three Baudelaire orphans after the death of their parents during a fire. The lives of Violet, Klaus and baby Sunny converts into a constant fight for living and changing homes. As they possess a fortune they got from their parents they represent an ...A Course In Miracles A Course in Miracles is so pure, so wonderful, so powerful, and so much more spiritually advanced than any other piece of the world's literature (past and present), that you have to actually experience it to believe it. But those whose minds are too attached to worldly thoughts, and lack the underlying thirst for true spiritual knowledge that is ...Skin Care Book Reviews The Wrinkle Cure By Nicholas Perricone, MDLet's start with a label that says "Dermatologist Tested". Well that Could mean that the product was tested but they may not have liked it. Tested yes but we would not know the results. Dr. Perricone did most of His testing and as the book goes along he admits what worked and what ...Who Is Jesus Christ For Us Today? A Response I found Dr. Cone’s book to be stimulating reading. His strong feelings were evident and I applaud his courage to criticize those theologians who are insensitive and indifferent to the subjectivity of Black Theology.Overall, I agree with most of Cone’s theology. We do part company however at certain intersections.I am not convinced ...Great Looking 2X4 Furniture; Book Review Title: Great-Looking 2X4 Furniture Informative Read … Recommended ... 5 stars The ReviewGreat-Looking 2X4 Furniture is another in the writers’ how-to book series. This one too is filled with step by step directions, lustrous snapshots, and a layout of a variety of furniture pieces to be made by utilizing a m ...Guide to Obtaining a #1 Ranking in the Search Engines: eBook Review When it comes to optimizing your site for search engines you basically have two choices: You can hire someone, with experience, to do it for you, or you can learn the basic principles of search engine optimization and do it yourself. If you choose the do-it-yourself route, then it is necessary to have some proper tools or written information if ...The Grapes of Wrath - John Steinbeck - A Book Review The Grapes of Wrath is a novel by John Steinbeck that exposes the desperate conditions under which the migratory farm families of America during the 1930's live under. The novel tells of one families migration west to California through the great economic depression of the 1930's. The Joad family had to abandon their home and their livelihoods. ...Envy of the Gods – Book Review Envy of the Gods, a science-fiction novel, has a cast of five main characters that struggle through a rise to leadership, tough ethical decisions, the re-discovery and use of ancient textbooks, and a society that strives for a better, more efficient way of life.In a ruthless and brutal age, much like our age of barbarian kingdoms, the nov ...Harry Potter Books - the Blurred Line Between Reality and Fantasy Because my conservative religion prohibits the practice of witchcraft I promised myself to read the first Harry Potter book to see if I can recommend it to my child. This was because the main character of this book is a practicing sorcerer/warlock and I would have a problem recommending it to my daughter. This was also because I know there are f ...Characters in the Hobbit - Tolkien Bilbo Baggins - he was a hobbit, a race of small people (no bigger than 4 or 5 feet), with lots of hair on the upper part of their feet, they enjoyed calm sorroundings and to live a quiet life. However, Bilbo was not the ordinary hobbit, because one part of his family was not very respectful, due to the fact that they were known to go on adven ...Bricks & Sticks: Ceiling Options Real estate ads and builders brochures often contain ceiling descriptions other than the standard eight-foot flat types that are found in many homes today. Understanding the options you have, especially when building a new home can create a unique space for your family to enjoy.Tray: A stepped ceiling, where as the design moves further aw ...Call Me Mommy - Book Review Retired police captain, Marshall Frank, has written another excellent read in his latest work, Call Me Mommy. Marshall is definitely a prolific writer – he has authored five books and hundreds of short stories and essays to date.I would classify Call Me Mommy as a tragic suspense saga. Marshall succeeds in making the book more realist ...Ideas Are Free - A Book Summary Without great ideas, no organization can stay afloat, much less flourish. Managers and top executives are constantly struggling to come up with big ones – creative marketing strategies, ingenious cost-cutting schemes and other corporate solutions that will save time and money and improve productivity. But what few of them realize is that right u ...Freakonomics - A Book By An Ecomomist That Isn't About Economics Steven D. Levitt is the economist. Stephen J Dubner is the writer. But Freakonomics is more about statistics and what to make of them than it is about economics.The book is a truly interesting read and reminds me of John Allen Paulos' book, Innumeracy. The authors of Freakonomics claim that there is no unifying theme to the book, but I d ...Politic$, Inc.: Principle, Not Profit With the 2008 presidential primaries well over a year away, the virtually unknown John Cox of Illinois is quietly moving through the political circles of New Hampshire, Iowa and South Carolina in an effort to generate possible support in his long shot campaign for the White House. Accompanying his efforts is his book, Politic$, Inc.: Principle, ...So Glad We Waited: A Hand-Holding Guide for Over-35 Parents (Book Review) About thirty-seven years ago when a friend of mine gave birth to a baby boy, she called herself Grandma Moses. That sounded far from the truth, because she was only forty-two and her baby and her family came along just fine through the child-raising process. It has been quite a few years now since her very brilliant son has become a successful m ..."Truth Told" author James Nash: BOOK REVIEW Truth Told By James (J.J.) Nash iUniverse, Inc. Review by William Phenn for Reader Views (3/06)J. J. Nash, a Jacksonville, Florida schoolteacher, has a penchant for fiction writing. After serving his country in the Navy, Nash went on to get his BA in public relations from the University of North Florida. How this ..."Sand Play for the Soul" by Paula Petrovic: Book Review Sand Play for the Soul: Awakening the Power of YOU to New Worlds of Possibility by Paula Petrovic Soul House Press (2006) ISBN 0977791408 Reviewed by Paige Lovitt for Reader Views (8/06)I had the pleasure of reading “Sand Play for the Soul” while I was camping in Flagstaff. Flagstaff is nearby Sedona, where ...The Hushed Willow - A Review The Hushed Willow by Lorna Joy Knox nee Ramsamugh is a collection of poetry that will stir your emotions as you embark on a rollercoaster ride through life. As the title suggests the poetry contained in The Hushed Willow is that of emotions and feelings that are kept silent, feelings of sadness, loss, betrayal and hurt. The author has an excep ...
|